Circleback vs Fathom

Share
Circleback

Circleback

AI Tool

67/100
Try with caution
Pick it if you are:
Solo professionals wanting free AI notes; Consultants and agencies with in-person meetings
Top complaint:
Circleback bot not joining meeting
Price:
Free plan, paid from $18/mo
6 Circleback errors & fixes →
Fathom

Fathom

Saas

64/100
Try with caution
Pick it if you are:
Individual professionals with many meetings; Budget-conscious startups
Top complaint:
Free plan only gets advanced AI summaries on 5 calls per month
Price:
Free plan, paid from $19/mo
12 Fathom errors & fixes →

Score Comparison

CirclebackareaFathom
◀67
Overall
64
66
Pricing
82▶
◀78
Usability
64
◀62
Performance
55
50
Support
50
◀62
Reliability
55
72
Onboarding
75▶
◀75
Mobile
40
65
Security
72▶
◀75
Integrations
60

Signals Comparison

Reliability

Circleback

  • Circleback bot not joining meeting(8/10)
  • Circleback transcript speaker mix-ups and silent gaps(6/10)

Fathom

  • Bot crashes during meetings and keeps rejoining(7/10)
  • Users lost access to years of transcripts(10/10)
  • Fathom notetaker doesn't join the meeting(8/10)
Pricing

Circleback

  • Circleback free plan only shows 30 days of history(6/10)
  • Is Circleback worth paying for? Integrations locked behind Pro(6/10)
  • Circleback pricing changed in 2026 and old reviews are wrong(4/10)
  • Circleback payments not refundable and cancel means downgrade(5/10)

Fathom

  • Free plan only gets advanced AI summaries on 5 calls per month(7/10)
  • Team plans need 2 seats and CRM field sync is Business-only(5/10)
Support

Circleback

  • Circleback support slow on billing and cancellations(6/10)
  • Circleback emails not arriving(4/10)

Fathom

  • Superhuman acquisition raises questions about Fathom's future(5/10)
Usability

Circleback

  • Circleback bot is visible and posts a chat message(5/10)
  • Circleback conversation analytics lighter than sales tools(4/10)

Fathom

  • Visible bot disrupts meetings and makes participants uncomfortable(7/10)
  • Timestamps extremely inaccurate(6/10)
  • Summaries jumble conversation flow and mix up tasks(5/10)
  • 'Your questions' section often irrelevant(4/10)
  • Bot takes up Zoom window and ends up in breakout rooms(5/10)
  • Transcription struggles with background noise and crosstalk(5/10)
  • Summaries lack detail and control(5/10)
  • Bot-free recording is Mac-only, Windows still 'coming soon'(6/10)
  • Transcripts can't be downloaded as a file(5/10)
Performance

Circleback

  • Circleback desktop app not recording(6/10)

Fathom

No signals

Security

Circleback

  • Circleback HIPAA and SSO only on Enterprise(5/10)

Fathom

  • Consent email doesn't stop recording if nobody answers(6/10)
Mobile

Circleback

No signals

Fathom

  • No Android app and the iOS app is only for in-person meetings(5/10)
Integrations

Circleback

No signals

Fathom

  • CRM sync issues unresolved for weeks(6/10)

Pricing Comparison

Circleback

Free
Free

Users: 2 teams

Storage: 30-day meeting and recording history

Limits: 30-day history, limited automations, 2 teams, no custom AI insights, no all-integration automations

Only the last 30 days of meetings and recordings are visible; automations limited; CRM integrations need Pro
Pro
$18.00/mo

Users: 5 teams

Storage: 1 year of recording storage

Limits: Roles, retention controls and free viewers need Business

Monthly price per a third-party review; trial length not published
Pro (annual)
Popular
$15.00/yr

Users: 5 teams

Storage: 1 year of recording storage

$180 per user per year billed upfront; reported non-refundable
Business
$29.00/mo

Users: Unlimited teams

Storage: 2 years of recording storage

Limits: SSO, SCIM and HIPAA need Enterprise

Monthly price per a third-party review
Business (annual)
$25.00/yr

Users: Unlimited teams

Storage: 2 years of recording storage

Enterprise
$35.00/yr

Users: Unlimited teams

Storage: Unlimited recording storage

Annual billing only

Fathom

Free
Free

Users: 1 user

Storage: Unlimited recordings and storage

Limits: Advanced summaries 5 calls/month, no AI action items, no AI follow-up emails, no custom summaries, no Ask Fathom (limited use), no shared team workspace

Advanced AI summaries only on the first 5 calls each month, then the basic General/Enhanced template; meeting banner and bot name can't be removed
Premium
$20.00/mo

Users: 1 user

Storage: Unlimited

Limits: Individual only, no shared workspace

Self-serve cancel only stops renewal; immediate cancellation needs an email to help@fathom.video
Premium (annual)
Popular
$16.00/yr

Users: 1 user

Storage: Unlimited

Limits: Individual only

Paid upfront for 12 months
Team
$19.00/mo

Users: 2 users minimum, per user

Storage: Unlimited

Limits: No CRM field sync, Deal View or scorecards

Per-user price with 2-seat minimum; CRM sync still capped at 3 users per domain; cancellation through success@fathom.video
Team (annual)
$15.00/yr

Users: 2 users minimum, per user

Storage: Unlimited

Limits: No CRM field sync, Deal View or scorecards

Annual commitment per seat
Business
$34.00/mo

Users: 2 users minimum, per user

Storage: Unlimited

Limits: No SSO/SCIM

Custom org summaries have a minimum requirement; Launch Assist onboarding is a paid add-on
Business (annual)
$25.00/yr

Users: 2 users minimum, per user

Storage: Unlimited

Limits: No SSO/SCIM

Annual commitment per seat
Enterprise (annual)
$35.00/yr

Users: Per user

Storage: Custom data retention

Limits: Pricing page layout is ambiguous; confirm the per-seat price with sales

Annual billing only

Feature Comparison

FeatureCirclebackFathom
Core
AI meeting notes and action items
Core Features
Meeting transcription

Unlimited on free

AI summaries

Advanced summaries on 5 calls/month free, unlimited on Premium

Action items

Limited on free

Highlight clips

Create shareable clips

Bot-free capture

Mac only (macOS 14.2+), Windows coming soon

Transcript download

Copy only; recordings download as MP4

Recording
Bot-free desktop recording

macOS and Windows

In-person meeting recording

Mobile app

Disable bot chat message

Per a third-party review

Integrations
CRM automations

Pro and above

Zoom integration

Full support

Google Meet integration

Full support

Microsoft Teams integration

Full support

CRM integrations

Max 3 users/domain on lower tiers; field sync on Business

Mobile app

iOS only (Oct 2026), in-person meetings; no Android

Analytics
Sales coaching and cross-meeting analytics

Per comparison articles

Team Features
Team collaboration

Team plan $19/user/month ($15 yearly), 2-seat minimum

Shared libraries

Team Edition+

Pricing
Unlimited storage

All plans including free

Free tier

Unlimited recording and transcripts

Security
SSO / SCIM

Enterprise plan only

Have an app idea? Our small team builds any software: web and mobile apps, games, desktop, AI tools. Price agreed together.

Talk to us
Circleback vs Fathom 2026 - Problems & Comparison | Try or Bye