ConvertKit (Kit) vs Substack

Share
Try with caution
Pick it if you are:
Course creators selling digital products
Top complaint:
Massive price hikes up to 4x for existing customers
Price:
Free plan, paid from $39/mo
10 ConvertKit (Kit) errors & fixes →
Substack

Substack

Platform

58/100
Try with caution
Pick it if you are:
Writers starting their first newsletter; Journalists and independent writers
Top complaint:
10% revenue cut adds up significantly
Price:
Free plan
10 Substack errors & fixes →

Score Comparison

ConvertKit (Kit)areaSubstack
55
Overall
58▶
40
Pricing
65▶
65
Usability
80▶
70
Performance
70
◀45
Support
20
65
Reliability
65
70
Onboarding
95▶
60
Mobile
60
50
Security
60▶
◀60
Integrations
25

Signals Comparison

Pricing

ConvertKit (Kit)

  • Massive price hikes up to 4x for existing customers(10/10)
  • Pricing increases steeply as subscriber list grows(9/10)
  • Starter plan severely limited - forces upgrade quickly(7/10)
  • Creator Pro required for basic features like newsletter referrals(6/10)

Substack

  • 10% revenue cut adds up significantly(9/10)
Support

ConvertKit (Kit)

  • Account deletion takes 6+ weeks despite promises(9/10)
  • Support quality inconsistent and slow response times(6/10)

Substack

  • Customer support is essentially non-existent(9/10)
Usability

ConvertKit (Kit)

  • Email builder is clunky and frustrating to use(7/10)
  • Interface becomes overwhelming with more features(6/10)

Substack

  • No API limits automation and integrations(8/10)
  • Lacks email marketing features(8/10)
  • Minimal signup and segmentation options(6/10)
  • Poor reading experience on the app(5/10)
  • Discoverability is challenging for new writers(6/10)
  • Not suitable for sales funnels or affiliate marketing(5/10)
  • Limited analytics and insights(5/10)
Customization

ConvertKit (Kit)

  • Limited template and design customization options(7/10)

Substack

  • Minimal design customization options(7/10)
Integrations

ConvertKit (Kit)

  • Integrations limited compared to larger platforms(5/10)

Substack

No signals

Reliability

ConvertKit (Kit)

  • Email deliverability issues reported by some users(7/10)

Substack

  • Billing issues and unexpected charges plague users(8/10)
  • Technical issues prevent publishing(7/10)
Security

ConvertKit (Kit)

  • GDPR compliance concerns with data deletion delays(8/10)

Substack

  • Content moderation controversy eroded trust(6/10)

Pricing Comparison

ConvertKit (Kit)

Newsletter (Free)
Free

Users: 1 user

Storage: Unlimited landing pages, forms and broadcasts; no storage cap published

Limits: No visual automations or email sequences, no Kit branding removal, 1 user only, no SMS or apps, no custom tracking domain, no engagement analytics

Kit branding stays on your emails and pages. Commerce transaction fee is 3.5% + 30 cents on sales. Hitting 10,001 subscribers forces a paid plan.
Creator
Popular
$39.00/mo

Users: 2 users

Storage: Not specified

Limits: No Subscriber Signals, engagement scoring, deliverability dashboard, referral system, or custom tracking domain (Pro only)

Price shown is for 1,000 subscribers and rises with list size (about $79/mo at 5,000 per third-party trackers). Upgrades to the next tier happen automatically; downgrades are manual. Paid Recommendations fee 23.5%. Refund only within 30 days of first payment.
Creator (annual)
$33.00/yr

Users: 2 users

Limits: No Subscriber Signals, engagement scoring, deliverability dashboard, referral system, or custom tracking domain (Pro only)

$390 per year at 1,000 subscribers (12 months for the price of 10). Downgrades take effect at the end of the annual period; no prorated refunds.
Pro
$79.00/mo

Users: Unlimited users

Storage: Not specified

Limits: Expensive for solo creators. Many 'Pro' features are basic in competitors.

Price shown is for 1,000 subscribers and rises with list size. Kit has been running a limited-time 25% off promo on annual Pro that applies to year one only, then renews at the standard rate.
Pro (annual)
$66.00/yr

Users: Unlimited users

Standard annual rate $66/mo per month equivalent at 1,000 subscribers; promo $50/mo applies to the first year only.

Substack

Free Publishing
Free

Users: Unlimited

Storage: Unlimited

Limits: No paid subscriptions, Limited customization, No advanced email features, No API

Limited features compared to paid alternatives. No automations, segmentation, or advanced analytics. No customer support.
Paid Subscriptions Enabled
Popular
Free

Users: Unlimited

Storage: Unlimited

Limits: 10% platform fee, ~13-14% total fees, No advanced email marketing, No API, Limited analytics

10% of subscription revenue to Substack + Stripe fees (2.9% + $0.30 + 0.7% recurring). Total ~13-14% of revenue. iOS in-app subscriptions are mandatory in supported countries: Apple takes 30% in year one (15% afterwards) and Substack raises the in-app price to compensate; no discount codes or founding tiers for in-app subscribers.
Substack Pro (By Invitation)
Free

Users: Unlimited

Storage: Unlimited

Limits: Invitation only, Not publicly available, Terms vary by creator

Only available to select high-profile writers. Higher revenue share negotiated. Not available to most creators.

Feature Comparison

FeatureConvertKit (Kit)Substack
Email
Email broadcasts

All plans

Pricing
Free to start

Completely free until paid subscriptions enabled

Automation
Automation sequences

Creator+ only

Visual automation builder

Creator+ only

Monetization
Built-in monetization

One-click paid subscriptions with Stripe

Native ad network

Not available

Core
Subscriber ownership

Export email list anytime

Marketing
Landing pages

All plans

Email automations

No automated sequences

Subscriber segmentation

Can't segment by behavior or interest

A/B testing

No subject line or content testing

Growth
Network discovery

Recommendations, Notes, cross-posts

Newsletter referral program

Creator Pro only

Audience
Subscriber tagging

All plans

Usability
Simple publishing

Clean editor, minimal learning curve

Integrations
Third-party integrations

Creator+ only

Public API

No API access whatsoever

Branding
Custom domain

Connect your own domain

Custom domains

Creator+ only

Design customization

Very limited options

Engagement
Community features

Notes, Chat, comments

Analytics
Subscriber scoring

Creator Pro only

Advanced reporting

Creator Pro only

Advanced analytics

Basic stats only

Access
Mobile apps

iOS and Android reading apps

Collaboration
Team collaboration

Creator Pro only

Selling
E-commerce integrations

Subscriptions only, no products

Support
Human customer support

AI chatbots only, 1.4/5 rating

Have an app idea? Our small team builds any software: web and mobile apps, games, desktop, AI tools. Price agreed together.

Talk to us
ConvertKit (Kit) vs Substack 2026 - Problems & Comparison | Try or Bye