FireAlpaca vs PaintTool SAI

Share
FireAlpaca
68/100
Try with caution
Pick it if you are:
Beginners learning digital art; Manga and comic hobbyists
Top complaint:
FireAlpaca pen pressure not working with drawing tablet
Price:
Free plan
9 FireAlpaca errors & fixes →
PaintTool SAI
61/100
Try with caution
Pick it if you are:
Anime and manga-style illustrators on Windows; Artists with older or low-spec PCs
Top complaint:
PaintTool SAI pen pressure not working
Price:
Free plan
11 PaintTool SAI errors & fixes →

Score Comparison

FireAlpacaareaPaintTool SAI
◀68
Overall
61
◀95
Pricing
82
75
Usability
80▶
68
Performance
76▶
◀50
Support
22
◀62
Reliability
52
◀78
Onboarding
68
◀45
Integrations
30

Signals Comparison

Usability

FireAlpaca

  • FireAlpaca pen pressure not working with drawing tablet(8/10)
  • Windows Ink causes delay or breaks pen shortcuts in FireAlpaca(6/10)
  • FireAlpaca is not built for professional illustration pipelines(5/10)

PaintTool SAI

  • PaintTool SAI pen pressure not working(8/10)
  • SAI feels outdated and lacks features compared with Clip Studio Paint(5/10)
  • PaintTool SAI UI too small on 4K screens(3/10)
Performance

FireAlpaca

  • FireAlpaca brush lag and delay when drawing(6/10)
  • FireAlpaca on Mac: app blocked or slow(5/10)
  • FireAlpaca slows down on high-resolution canvases(5/10)

PaintTool SAI

  • SAI 'not enough memory' on large canvases(6/10)
Reliability

FireAlpaca

  • FireAlpaca not opening or not working(8/10)
  • Lost work after a crash: FireAlpaca autosave and recovery(7/10)

PaintTool SAI

  • SAI license certificate not recognized, still says trial or preview(8/10)
  • SAI Ver.2 is still a 'technical preview' years later(6/10)
  • PaintTool SAI license purchase and certificate download went offline (Oct 2026)(7/10)
  • SAI file corrupted or lost after saving(9/10)
Customization

FireAlpaca

  • FireAlpaca is limited compared with Krita and Clip Studio Paint(5/10)

PaintTool SAI

  • PaintTool SAI has no Mac, iPad or Linux version(7/10)
  • Old custom brush textures rejected by SAI 2(4/10)
Pricing

FireAlpaca

  • FireAlpaca SE costs extra, free version has fewer features(4/10)

PaintTool SAI

  • No refunds on a PaintTool SAI license(4/10)
Support

FireAlpaca

  • FireAlpaca support is community-based with few official fixes(5/10)

PaintTool SAI

  • One-man developer: slow replies and no individual bug support(6/10)
Integrations

FireAlpaca

  • FireAlpaca files and MediBang cloud overlap confuse users(4/10)

PaintTool SAI

  • SAI 2 'WinTab driver has returned an error' with Wacom tablets(6/10)

Pricing Comparison

FireAlpaca

FireAlpaca (free)
Popular
Free

Users: 1 user per install

Storage: Local files only

Limits: No timelapse recording, no brush scripting, fewer performance optimizations than SE

None for the free app. FireAlpaca SE is a separate paid app.
FireAlpaca SE (one-time, Steam)
$39.99/mo

Limits: Not on Steam Family Sharing

Price varies by region and sale; some users report save options need launching through the Steam client

PaintTool SAI

Free trial / Ver.2 preview without license
Free

Users: 1.0

Limits: No save or load after the trial (Ver.1), no save or load at all in the unlicensed Ver.2 preview, Windows only

Ver.1 open/save is disabled after 31 days; the Ver.2 preview locks save/load until you install a license certificate
Ver.1 Software License (5,500 JPY, includes Ver.2)
Popular
$36.00/mo

Users: 1.0

Limits: One active computer per license, Windows only

Priced at 5,500 JPY incl. tax; the USD amount varies with the exchange rate. Not refundable. Tied to one PC's System ID, so hardware changes or a new PC need a new certificate.

Feature Comparison

FeatureFireAlpacaPaintTool SAI
Painting
Layers and blend modes
Custom brushes

Five brush texture types

Timelapse recording

SE edition only

Drawing
Line stabilizer
Pressure-sensitive brushes (WinTab / Windows Ink)
Vector linework layers
Perspective rulers

Ver.2 only

Animation
Animation
Animation timeline
Comics
3D perspective tool
Files
Autosave backups

Backup saved separately, deleted on manual save

Layers
Text layers

Ver.2 only; CFF fonts not supported yet

Performance
64-bit build

Ver.2 only; Ver.1 is 32-bit

Platforms
Mobile app

Use MediBang Paint on mobile

Mac / iPad / Linux app

Windows only

Have an app idea? Our small team builds any software: web and mobile apps, games, desktop, AI tools. Price agreed together.

Talk to us
FireAlpaca vs PaintTool SAI 2026 - Problems & Comparison | Try or Bye