- Pick it if you are:
- Beginners learning digital art; Manga and comic hobbyists
- Top complaint:
- FireAlpaca pen pressure not working with drawing tablet
- Price:
- Free plan
- Pick it if you are:
- Anime and manga-style illustrators on Windows; Artists with older or low-spec PCs
- Top complaint:
- PaintTool SAI pen pressure not working
- Price:
- Free plan
Score Comparison
Signals Comparison
FireAlpaca
- FireAlpaca pen pressure not working with drawing tablet(8/10)
- Windows Ink causes delay or breaks pen shortcuts in FireAlpaca(6/10)
- FireAlpaca is not built for professional illustration pipelines(5/10)
PaintTool SAI
- PaintTool SAI pen pressure not working(8/10)
- SAI feels outdated and lacks features compared with Clip Studio Paint(5/10)
- PaintTool SAI UI too small on 4K screens(3/10)
FireAlpaca
- FireAlpaca brush lag and delay when drawing(6/10)
- FireAlpaca on Mac: app blocked or slow(5/10)
- FireAlpaca slows down on high-resolution canvases(5/10)
PaintTool SAI
- SAI 'not enough memory' on large canvases(6/10)
FireAlpaca
- FireAlpaca not opening or not working(8/10)
- Lost work after a crash: FireAlpaca autosave and recovery(7/10)
PaintTool SAI
- SAI license certificate not recognized, still says trial or preview(8/10)
- SAI Ver.2 is still a 'technical preview' years later(6/10)
- PaintTool SAI license purchase and certificate download went offline (Oct 2026)(7/10)
- SAI file corrupted or lost after saving(9/10)
FireAlpaca
- FireAlpaca is limited compared with Krita and Clip Studio Paint(5/10)
PaintTool SAI
- PaintTool SAI has no Mac, iPad or Linux version(7/10)
- Old custom brush textures rejected by SAI 2(4/10)
FireAlpaca
- FireAlpaca SE costs extra, free version has fewer features(4/10)
PaintTool SAI
- No refunds on a PaintTool SAI license(4/10)
FireAlpaca
- FireAlpaca support is community-based with few official fixes(5/10)
PaintTool SAI
- One-man developer: slow replies and no individual bug support(6/10)
FireAlpaca
- FireAlpaca files and MediBang cloud overlap confuse users(4/10)
PaintTool SAI
- SAI 2 'WinTab driver has returned an error' with Wacom tablets(6/10)
Pricing Comparison
FireAlpaca
Users: 1 user per install
Storage: Local files only
Limits: No timelapse recording, no brush scripting, fewer performance optimizations than SE
Limits: Not on Steam Family Sharing
PaintTool SAI
Users: 1.0
Limits: No save or load after the trial (Ver.1), no save or load at all in the unlicensed Ver.2 preview, Windows only
Users: 1.0
Limits: One active computer per license, Windows only
Feature Comparison
| Feature | FireAlpaca | PaintTool SAI |
|---|---|---|
| Painting | ||
| Layers and blend modes | ||
| Custom brushes Five brush texture types | ||
| Timelapse recording SE edition only | ||
| Drawing | ||
| Line stabilizer | ||
| Pressure-sensitive brushes (WinTab / Windows Ink) | ||
| Vector linework layers | ||
| Perspective rulers Ver.2 only | ||
| Animation | ||
| Animation | ||
| Animation timeline | ||
| Comics | ||
| 3D perspective tool | ||
| Files | ||
| Autosave backups Backup saved separately, deleted on manual save | ||
| Layers | ||
| Text layers Ver.2 only; CFF fonts not supported yet | ||
| Performance | ||
| 64-bit build Ver.2 only; Ver.1 is 32-bit | ||
| Platforms | ||
| Mobile app Use MediBang Paint on mobile | ||
| Mac / iPad / Linux app Windows only | ||
Have an app idea? Our small team builds any software: web and mobile apps, games, desktop, AI tools. Price agreed together.
Talk to us