Try or ByeTry or Bye
ProductsCategoriesTop PicksCompareFixesBudget CalcContact
Try or ByeTry or Bye

Where digital products disappoint — based on real user feedback patterns.

© 2026 Try or Bye. All rights reserved.

Explore

  • All Products
  • Categories
  • Compare

Insights

  • Signals
  • Problems
  • Price Increases Report
  • Apps Users Regret Paying For
  • Methodology
  • Contact

Legal

  • Privacy Policy
  • Terms of Service
  1. Home
  2. Compare
  3. Hemingway Editor vs ProWritingAid

Hemingway EditorvsProWritingAid

Website
vs
Saas
ScoresSignalsPricingFeatures

Score Comparison

65
Overall
55
85
Pricing
72
75
Usability
58
55
Performance
45
60
Support
60
75
Reliability
50
90
Onboarding
50
40
Mobile
30
75
Security
55
50
Integrations
55
Hemingway EditorProWritingAid

Signals Comparison

Performance

Hemingway Editor

  • No grammar checking - only style analysis(8/10)
  • Flags EVERY long sentence as a problem(7/10)
  • AI rewrites strip unique voice and feel generic(7/10)
  • Doesn't recognize idioms or colloquialisms(6/10)
  • AI rewrites sometimes make sentences more complex(6/10)
  • Passive voice detection inconsistent(6/10)

ProWritingAid

  • Word add-in crashes and freezes Word(9/10)
  • Struggles with large documents over 800 words(8/10)
  • Plagiarism checker extremely slow(6/10)
Usability

Hemingway Editor

  • Free version doesn't help fix highlighted errors(6/10)
  • Not suitable for long documents(6/10)
  • No explanations for why changes suggested(5/10)

ProWritingAid

  • Inconsistent detection and false positives(7/10)
  • Steep learning curve with overwhelming reports(5/10)
  • Cannot save grammar preferences(6/10)
  • Mishandles dialogue tags and creative writing(6/10)
Pricing

Hemingway Editor

  • Multiple confusing purchase options(5/10)
  • Monthly AI rewrite limits feel restrictive(5/10)

ProWritingAid

  • Free version limited to 500 words(6/10)
  • Premium $30/month feels expensive(6/10)
  • Refunds only within 3 days of purchase(6/10)
Reliability

Hemingway Editor

  • Plus version requires internet - no offline AI(5/10)

ProWritingAid

No signals

Integrations

Hemingway Editor

No signals

ProWritingAid

  • Chrome extension doesn't work on many websites(7/10)
  • Scrivener integration loses changes(8/10)
  • Gmail and email integration unreliable(5/10)
Security

Hemingway Editor

No signals

ProWritingAid

  • AI rephrasing triggers plagiarism detection(9/10)
Support

Hemingway Editor

No signals

ProWritingAid

  • No live chat or phone support(5/10)

Pricing Comparison

Hemingway Editor

Free (Web)
Free

Users: 1 user

Limits: Must copy text into web editor, no export options, no suggestions for fixes

No AI rewrites, no grammar checking, no offline use, no saving documents
Desktop App
Popular
$19.99/mo

Users: 1 user

Limits: No AI features, no automatic updates to new versions, no cloud sync

No AI rewrites included, no grammar checking, must buy separately for Windows AND Mac
Plus (Individual)
$8.33/mo

Users: 1 user

Limits: 5,000 sentence limit may not suffice for heavy users, AI requires connectivity

$100/year upfront, monthly rewrite limits, requires internet for AI features
Plus (Pro)
$25/mo

Users: 1 user

Limits: Still caps at 10,000 - may not suit agencies or heavy publishing schedules

Significant price increase for double the rewrites, still has monthly caps
Team Plan
Free

Users: Multiple users

Limits: Pricing not transparent, must contact sales

Custom pricing requires contact, per-user limits still apply

ProWritingAid

Free
Free

Users: 1 user

Limits: 500 word limit per check, Web editor only, Very limited daily usage

No integrations (Word, Chrome, Scrivener), No plagiarism checks, No desktop app
Premium
$30/mo

Users: 1 user

Limits: No plagiarism checker included, Standard support only

Plagiarism checks cost extra (need Premium Pro), No priority support
Premium (Annual)
Popular
$120/yr

Users: 1 user

Limits: No plagiarism checker, No priority support

Plagiarism checks still cost extra, Only 3-day refund window
Premium (Lifetime)
$399/mo

Users: 1 user

Limits: No plagiarism checker, Standard support only

Plagiarism checks still require upgrade to Premium Pro or separate purchase
Premium Pro
$36/mo

Users: 1 user

Limits: Plagiarism checks limited to 60/year

Only 60 plagiarism checks per year may not be enough for heavy users
Premium Pro (Annual)
$144/yr

Users: 1 user

Limits: 60 plagiarism checks/year limit

60 plagiarism checks may run out, Non-refundable after 3 days
Premium Pro (Lifetime)
$699/mo

Users: 1 user

Limits: 60 plagiarism checks/year (renews annually)

Large upfront cost, Plagiarism check limits still apply annually

Feature Comparison

FeatureHemingway EditorProWritingAid
Core Features
Readability grade scoring

Shows grade level

Complex sentence highlighting

Yellow/red coding

Style suggestions

25+ writing reports

Passive voice detection

Green highlighting

Plagiarism checker

Premium Pro only, slow and limited

Adverb flagging

Blue highlighting

Grammar checking

NOT included - needs separate tool

AI Features
AI rephrasing

May trigger AI detection

Integrations
Microsoft Word integration

Buggy, crashes on large docs

Google Docs integration

No Pageless mode support

Scrivener integration

Loses changes, requires app closed

WordPress publishing

Desktop app only

Chrome extension

Doesn't work on all sites

Medium publishing

Desktop app only

Desktop app

Windows and Mac

Browser extension

Not available

Mobile app

No native mobile app

Plus Features
AI rewrites

Plus subscription only

Desktop Features
Offline editing

Desktop app only

Pricing
Free web version

Unlimited use

One-time purchase option

$19.99 desktop

Lifetime plan

$399 Premium, $699 Premium Pro

Free tier

500 words only, very limited

Usability
Offline mode

Desktop app only, limited features

Team Features
Team collaboration

Basic team plans available