Karabiner-Elements vs Keyboard Maestro

Share
Try
Pick it if you are:
Developers and power users; Vim and terminal users
Top complaint:
Built-in MacBook keyboard remapping broke on macOS 26.4
Price:
Free plan
10 Karabiner-Elements errors & fixes →
Try
Pick it if you are:
Mac power users with repetitive tasks; Text expansion users on Mac
Top complaint:
Keyboard Maestro stops working after macOS update
12 Keyboard Maestro errors & fixes →

Score Comparison

Karabiner-ElementsareaKeyboard Maestro
70
Overall
70
◀98
Pricing
90
◀55
Usability
45
80
Performance
82▶
45
Support
85▶
58
Reliability
60▶
◀45
Onboarding
40
65
Integrations
85▶

Signals Comparison

Reliability

Karabiner-Elements

  • Karabiner-Elements stopped working after a macOS update(7/10)
  • Built-in MacBook keyboard remapping broke on macOS 26.4(9/10)
  • Mouse scroll wheel broken on macOS Tahoe until Karabiner ignores the mouse(5/10)

Keyboard Maestro

  • Keyboard Maestro macros not triggering(8/10)
  • Keyboard Maestro stops working after macOS update(9/10)
  • Typed string triggers stop working(7/10)
  • Click at Found Image not working(6/10)
  • Keyboard Maestro problems on macOS Tahoe(7/10)
  • Secure Input blocks Keyboard Maestro(6/10)
  • Keyboard Maestro Engine not launching at login(6/10)
Onboarding

Karabiner-Elements

  • Driver alert keeps showing up(7/10)
  • Needs several macOS permissions before it works(6/10)

Keyboard Maestro

No signals

Usability

Karabiner-Elements

  • Editing karabiner.json by hand is the only way for advanced rules(5/10)
  • Control-eject shortcut does not work while running(3/10)

Keyboard Maestro

  • Keyboard Maestro is too complicated for beginners(6/10)
  • Keyboard Maestro interface looks dated(5/10)
Integrations

Karabiner-Elements

  • Hyper key conflicts with BetterTouchTool and Keyboard Maestro(5/10)
  • Hammerspoon shortcuts stop registering with 'modify events' on(5/10)
  • Logitech Logi Options+ Fn keys stop responding(4/10)

Keyboard Maestro

  • Browser and app actions fail (Safari, Chrome, Adobe)(5/10)
Customization

Karabiner-Elements

  • Caps Lock LED stops working(4/10)

Keyboard Maestro

  • Keyboard Maestro is Mac only(5/10)
Support

Karabiner-Elements

  • Updates and beta versions force reinstalls(5/10)

Keyboard Maestro

No signals

Pricing

Karabiner-Elements

  • Free tool, but a donation is requested(1/10)

Keyboard Maestro

  • Paid upgrade for each major version(3/10)
Performance

Karabiner-Elements

No signals

Keyboard Maestro

  • Macros type or paste text too fast and drop characters(5/10)

Pricing Comparison

Karabiner-Elements

Free
Popular
Free

Limits: macOS only; no paid tier, so no official support contract

Keyboard Maestro

Keyboard Maestro 11
Popular
$36.00/mo

Users: 1 user per license

Limits: macOS only

Paid upgrade from older versions (US$25); purchases since 1 March 2023 upgrade to v11 free; applicable tax extra
Upgrade from earlier version
$25.00/mo

Users: 1 user per license

Limits: Requires a previous license

Free if purchased since 1 March 2023

Feature Comparison

FeatureKarabiner-ElementsKeyboard Maestro
Core
Simple key remapping
Complex modifications (JSON)
Per-device rules
Mouse button remapping
Triggers
Hotkey triggers
Typed string (text expansion) triggers

Does not fire in password fields

Actions
Image search and click

Needs Screen Recording permission

Run shell, AppleScript, JavaScript
Platform
Windows or Linux support
Logic
Variables and conditions
Support
Official paid support
Utilities
Clipboard history
Platforms
Windows or Linux version

macOS only

iPhone / iPad app
Pricing
Free trial

Trial download linked from the official site

Have an app idea? Our small team builds any software: web and mobile apps, games, desktop, AI tools. Price agreed together.

Talk to us
Karabiner-Elements vs Keyboard Maestro 2026 - Problems & Comparison | Try or Bye