Try
- Pick it if you are:
- Developers and power users; Vim and terminal users
- Top complaint:
- Built-in MacBook keyboard remapping broke on macOS 26.4
- Price:
- Free plan
Try
- Pick it if you are:
- Mac power users with repetitive tasks; Text expansion users on Mac
- Top complaint:
- Keyboard Maestro stops working after macOS update
Score Comparison
Karabiner-ElementsareaKeyboard Maestro
70
Overall70
◀98
Pricing90
◀55
Usability45
80
Performance82▶
45
Support85▶
58
Reliability60▶
◀45
Onboarding40
65
Integrations85▶
Signals Comparison
Reliability
Karabiner-Elements
- Karabiner-Elements stopped working after a macOS update(7/10)
- Built-in MacBook keyboard remapping broke on macOS 26.4(9/10)
- Mouse scroll wheel broken on macOS Tahoe until Karabiner ignores the mouse(5/10)
Keyboard Maestro
- Keyboard Maestro macros not triggering(8/10)
- Keyboard Maestro stops working after macOS update(9/10)
- Typed string triggers stop working(7/10)
- Click at Found Image not working(6/10)
- Keyboard Maestro problems on macOS Tahoe(7/10)
- Secure Input blocks Keyboard Maestro(6/10)
- Keyboard Maestro Engine not launching at login(6/10)
Onboarding
Karabiner-Elements
- Driver alert keeps showing up(7/10)
- Needs several macOS permissions before it works(6/10)
Keyboard Maestro
No signals
Usability
Karabiner-Elements
- Editing karabiner.json by hand is the only way for advanced rules(5/10)
- Control-eject shortcut does not work while running(3/10)
Keyboard Maestro
- Keyboard Maestro is too complicated for beginners(6/10)
- Keyboard Maestro interface looks dated(5/10)
Integrations
Karabiner-Elements
- Hyper key conflicts with BetterTouchTool and Keyboard Maestro(5/10)
- Hammerspoon shortcuts stop registering with 'modify events' on(5/10)
- Logitech Logi Options+ Fn keys stop responding(4/10)
Keyboard Maestro
- Browser and app actions fail (Safari, Chrome, Adobe)(5/10)
Customization
Karabiner-Elements
- Caps Lock LED stops working(4/10)
Keyboard Maestro
- Keyboard Maestro is Mac only(5/10)
Support
Karabiner-Elements
- Updates and beta versions force reinstalls(5/10)
Keyboard Maestro
No signals
Pricing
Karabiner-Elements
- Free tool, but a donation is requested(1/10)
Keyboard Maestro
- Paid upgrade for each major version(3/10)
Performance
Karabiner-Elements
No signals
Keyboard Maestro
- Macros type or paste text too fast and drop characters(5/10)
Pricing Comparison
Karabiner-Elements
Free
PopularLimits: macOS only; no paid tier, so no official support contract
Keyboard Maestro
Keyboard Maestro 11
PopularUsers: 1 user per license
Limits: macOS only
Paid upgrade from older versions (US$25); purchases since 1 March 2023 upgrade to v11 free; applicable tax extra
Upgrade from earlier version
Users: 1 user per license
Limits: Requires a previous license
Free if purchased since 1 March 2023
Feature Comparison
| Feature | Karabiner-Elements | Keyboard Maestro |
|---|---|---|
| Core | ||
| Simple key remapping | ||
| Complex modifications (JSON) | ||
| Per-device rules | ||
| Mouse button remapping | ||
| Triggers | ||
| Hotkey triggers | ||
| Typed string (text expansion) triggers Does not fire in password fields | ||
| Actions | ||
| Image search and click Needs Screen Recording permission | ||
| Run shell, AppleScript, JavaScript | ||
| Platform | ||
| Windows or Linux support | ||
| Logic | ||
| Variables and conditions | ||
| Support | ||
| Official paid support | ||
| Utilities | ||
| Clipboard history | ||
| Platforms | ||
| Windows or Linux version macOS only | ||
| iPhone / iPad app | ||
| Pricing | ||
| Free trial Trial download linked from the official site | ||
Have an app idea? Our small team builds any software: web and mobile apps, games, desktop, AI tools. Price agreed together.
Talk to us