NordVPN vs Surfshark

Share
NordVPN
70/100
Try
Pick it if you are:
Streamers unblocking other regions; Privacy-conscious everyday users
Top complaint:
Why is NordVPN renewal so expensive?
Price:
From $3.49/mo
9 NordVPN errors & fixes →
Surfshark
69/100
Try with caution
Pick it if you are:
Families and people with many devices; Budget buyers willing to re-buy every 2 years
Top complaint:
Surfshark renewal price much higher than the price you signed up at
Price:
From $1.78/mo
10 Surfshark errors & fixes →

Score Comparison

NordVPNareaSurfshark
◀70
Overall
69
48
Pricing
62▶
80
Usability
80
◀84
Performance
68
55
Support
58▶
◀70
Reliability
64
80
Onboarding
82▶
◀76
Mobile
75
◀84
Security
78

Signals Comparison

Pricing

NordVPN

  • Why is NordVPN renewal so expensive?(8/10)
  • NordVPN auto-renewed without warning(8/10)
  • NordVPN refund not possible for App Store purchases(6/10)
  • NordVPN 10 device limit(4/10)
  • NordVPN upsells: Complete, Prime and paid add-ons(4/10)

Surfshark

  • Surfshark renewal price much higher than the price you signed up at(8/10)
  • Surfshark One+ price raised twice in early 2026(5/10)
  • Surfshark auto-renewed without warning and won't refund(8/10)
  • Surfshark monthly plan is expensive(5/10)
  • Antivirus and identity extras inflate the price(4/10)
Support

NordVPN

  • NordVPN refused refund after renewal(8/10)
  • NordVPN support gives generic answers(5/10)

Surfshark

  • Surfshark customer service unhelpful on refunds(6/10)
Reliability

NordVPN

  • NordVPN keeps disconnecting or won't connect(7/10)
  • NordVPN not working with Netflix (proxy error)(6/10)

Surfshark

  • Surfshark not working with Netflix (proxy error)(6/10)
  • Surfshark keeps disconnecting(7/10)
  • Surfshark not connecting or stuck on connecting(7/10)
Usability

NordVPN

  • NordVPN Threat Protection blocking websites(5/10)
  • No internet after disconnecting NordVPN(6/10)

Surfshark

  • Websites and Google show CAPTCHAs or block Surfshark(5/10)
  • Hard to find how to cancel Surfshark(5/10)
Onboarding

NordVPN

  • NordVPN login not working or stuck in a login loop(6/10)

Surfshark

No signals

Integrations

NordVPN

  • NordVPN Meshnet shutdown scare(5/10)

Surfshark

No signals

Performance

NordVPN

  • Why is NordVPN so slow on some servers?(5/10)

Surfshark

  • Why is Surfshark so slow?(5/10)

Pricing Comparison

NordVPN

Basic (2-year)
$3.49/mo

Users: 10

Limits: No antivirus, password manager or cloud storage

Billed upfront (about $94 for the first 27 months). Renews at $139.08/year plus tax; auto-renewal is on by default
Complete (2-year)
Popular
$4.49/mo

Users: 10

Storage: 1 TB

Billed upfront (about $121 for the first 27 months). Renews at $219.48/year plus tax
Prime (2-year)
$7.49/mo

Users: 10

Storage: 1 TB

Limits: Identity features mainly aimed at US users

Billed upfront; renews at a much higher yearly rate (reported around $296/year). Third-party sources disagree on the exact intro price
Basic (monthly)
$14.99/mo

Users: 10

More than 4x the 2-year intro rate; Complete monthly is $19.99
Dedicated IP add-on
$3.69/mo
Starting price on a 2-year plan; extra on top of any VPN plan

Surfshark

Starter (2-year)
$1.78/mo

Limits: VPN-focused tier; antivirus and identity tools need One or One+

Billed about $48.06 upfront for 27 months; then renews at $79/year before tax (about 230% more)
One (2-year)
Popular
$2.08/mo

Limits: Data removal (Incogni) is in One+ only

Billed about $56.16 upfront for 27 months; then renews at $99/year before tax
One+ (2-year)
$4.18/mo

Limits: Incogni only for US, UK, EU, Swiss and Canadian residents; identity theft coverage US-only (not New York)

Billed about $112.86 upfront for 27 months; then renews at $119/year before tax
Starter (1-year)
$2.98/mo

Limits: Higher per-month price than the 2-year deal

Billed upfront; renews at $79/year before tax
Starter (monthly)
$15.45/mo

Limits: About 8x the 2-year monthly rate

No 30-day renewal reminder email for 1-month plans; One monthly is $17.95 and One+ about $20.85

Feature Comparison

FeatureNordVPNSurfshark
Core
NordLynx (WireGuard-based) protocol

Fastest option; OpenVPN also available

Unlimited simultaneous devices

All plans

WireGuard and OpenVPN protocols

Settings > VPN Settings > Protocol

Split tunneling
IPv6 support

Surfshark says it does not support IPv6; disable it to avoid connection issues

Obfuscated servers

For restrictive networks; slower

Dedicated IP

Paid add-on

Unlimited devices

10 simultaneous devices

Security
Kill switch

Windows has app-level and internet-level modes

Threat Protection

Ad/malware/phishing blocking; can cause false positives

Double VPN / Onion over VPN

Large speed loss

Networking
Meshnet

Shutdown announced for Dec 2025, then reversed

Bundle
Antivirus

One and One+

Incogni data removal

One+; US, UK, EU, Swiss and Canadian residents

Pricing
Free plan or free trial

30-day money-back guarantee instead

Have an app idea? Our small team builds any software: web and mobile apps, games, desktop, AI tools. Price agreed together.

Talk to us
NordVPN vs Surfshark 2026 - Problems & Comparison | Try or Bye