Clip Studio Paint vs PaintTool SAI

Share
Try with caution
Pick it if you are:
Manga and comic artists; Line-art illustrators
Top complaint:
Pen pressure not working in Clip Studio Paint
Price:
From $4.49/mo
9 Clip Studio Paint errors & fixes →
PaintTool SAI
61/100
Try with caution
Pick it if you are:
Anime and manga-style illustrators on Windows; Artists with older or low-spec PCs
Top complaint:
PaintTool SAI pen pressure not working
Price:
Free plan
11 PaintTool SAI errors & fixes →

Score Comparison

Clip Studio PaintareaPaintTool SAI
◀69
Overall
61
62
Pricing
82▶
70
Usability
80▶
64
Performance
76▶
◀60
Support
22
◀66
Reliability
52
62
Onboarding
68▶
◀68
Mobile
–
◀70
Integrations
30

Signals Comparison

Pricing

Clip Studio Paint

  • Why do I have to pay for the Update Pass to get new features?(6/10)
  • Clip Studio Paint EX is so expensive ($277)(6/10)
  • Clip Studio Paint Ver. 5.0 price went up(4/10)
  • No upgrade path from Ver. 1-3 to Ver. 5(5/10)

PaintTool SAI

  • No refunds on a PaintTool SAI license(4/10)
Support

Clip Studio Paint

  • No refunds on Clip Studio store and desktop plans(6/10)

PaintTool SAI

  • One-man developer: slow replies and no individual bug support(6/10)
Performance

Clip Studio Paint

  • Clip Studio Paint is slow or laggy on big canvases(7/10)
  • Clip Studio Paint crashes on startup(8/10)

PaintTool SAI

  • SAI 'not enough memory' on large canvases(6/10)
Integrations

Clip Studio Paint

  • Pen pressure not working in Clip Studio Paint(8/10)

PaintTool SAI

  • SAI 2 'WinTab driver has returned an error' with Wacom tablets(6/10)
Reliability

Clip Studio Paint

  • Shortcuts stop working after switching apps (Ver. 5.0 Windows)(6/10)
  • Offline use limited to 15 days(4/10)

PaintTool SAI

  • SAI license certificate not recognized, still says trial or preview(8/10)
  • SAI Ver.2 is still a 'technical preview' years later(6/10)
  • PaintTool SAI license purchase and certificate download went offline (Oct 2026)(7/10)
  • SAI file corrupted or lost after saving(9/10)
Mobile

Clip Studio Paint

  • Clip Studio Paint iPad crashes with many canvases open(7/10)
  • Can't type multi-digit numbers on iPad floating keyboard(4/10)

PaintTool SAI

No signals

Onboarding

Clip Studio Paint

  • Clip Studio Paint is overwhelming for beginners(5/10)

PaintTool SAI

No signals

Usability

Clip Studio Paint

No signals

PaintTool SAI

  • PaintTool SAI pen pressure not working(8/10)
  • SAI feels outdated and lacks features compared with Clip Studio Paint(5/10)
  • PaintTool SAI UI too small on 4K screens(3/10)
Customization

Clip Studio Paint

No signals

PaintTool SAI

  • PaintTool SAI has no Mac, iPad or Linux version(7/10)
  • Old custom brush textures rejected by SAI 2(4/10)

Pricing Comparison

Clip Studio Paint

PRO Ver. 5.0 (one-time, Windows/macOS)
Popular
$63.00/mo

Users: 1 computer at a time

Limits: Windows and macOS only

New features after the 5.0 release need an Update Pass ($10.99/yr) or a plan; no multi-page comics or animation beyond basic (EX features)
EX Ver. 5.0 (one-time, Windows/macOS)
$277.00/mo

Users: 1 computer at a time

Limits: Windows and macOS only

Update Pass $31.99/yr for new features after 5.0
PRO Update Pass (12 months)
$10.99/yr

Limits: Requires an existing perpetual license; $10.99 is the yearly total

Renews automatically; first-time users get a bonus month; when it lapses you revert to your last perpetual version (Ver. 4.0.10 for Ver. 4 owners)
EX Update Pass (12 months)
$31.99/yr

Limits: Requires an existing perpetual EX license

Renews automatically; $31.99 is the yearly total
PRO Single-device plan (monthly)
$4.49/mo

Users: 1 device

Limits: Single device

No refunds on Clip Studio store/desktop plans; cancel before renewal
PRO Single-device plan (annual, $26.99/yr)
Popular
$2.25/yr

Users: 1 device

Limits: Single device

Billed $26.99 per year, auto-renews, no refund
EX Single-device plan (monthly)
$8.99/mo

Users: 1 device

Limits: Single device

No refunds on Clip Studio store/desktop plans
EX Single-device plan (annual, $76.99/yr)
$6.42/yr

Users: 1 device

Limits: Single device

Billed $76.99 per year, auto-renews, no refund

PaintTool SAI

Free trial / Ver.2 preview without license
Free

Users: 1.0

Limits: No save or load after the trial (Ver.1), no save or load at all in the unlicensed Ver.2 preview, Windows only

Ver.1 open/save is disabled after 31 days; the Ver.2 preview locks save/load until you install a license certificate
Ver.1 Software License (5,500 JPY, includes Ver.2)
Popular
$36.00/mo

Users: 1.0

Limits: One active computer per license, Windows only

Priced at 5,500 JPY incl. tax; the USD amount varies with the exchange rate. Not refundable. Tied to one PC's System ID, so hardware changes or a new PC need a new certificate.

Feature Comparison

FeatureClip Studio PaintPaintTool SAI
Drawing
Vector layers
Line stabilizer
Pressure-sensitive brushes (WinTab / Windows Ink)
Vector linework layers
Perspective rulers

Ver.2 only

Smart Shape

New in Ver. 5.0

Perspective and symmetry rulers
Comics
Comic panels, balloons, screentones

Multi-page projects need EX

Reference
3D models and posing

Ver. 5.0 adds hand models

Animation
Frame animation

Long animation in EX

Animation timeline
Layers
Text layers

Ver.2 only; CFF fonts not supported yet

Performance
64-bit build

Ver.2 only; Ver.1 is 32-bit

Platform
Offline use

15 days on Windows/macOS

Linux version

Not supported

Platforms
Mac / iPad / Linux app

Windows only

Have an app idea? Our small team builds any software: web and mobile apps, games, desktop, AI tools. Price agreed together.

Talk to us
Clip Studio Paint vs PaintTool SAI 2026 - Problems & Comparison | Try or Bye