Otter.ai vs Sembly AI

Share
Otter.ai
48/100
Bye
Pick it if you are:
Students recording lectures; Podcast producers and content creators
Top complaint:
Federal class-action lawsuit over privacy violations
Price:
Free plan, paid from $16.99/mo
10 Otter.ai errors & fixes →
Sembly AI

Sembly AI

AI Tool

60/100
Try with caution
Pick it if you are:
Consultants and agencies producing client deliverables; Multilingual and international teams
Top complaint:
Sembly didn't join my meeting (stuck in the lobby or waiting room)
Price:
Free plan, paid from $14/mo
11 Sembly AI errors & fixes →

Score Comparison

Otter.aiareaSembly AI
48
Overall
60▶
50
Pricing
55▶
55
Usability
66▶
60
Performance
60
25
Support
55▶
50
Reliability
52▶
60
Onboarding
65▶
◀65
Mobile
45
30
Security
72▶
◀70
Integrations
62

Signals Comparison

Security

Otter.ai

  • Federal class-action lawsuit over privacy violations(10/10)
  • OtterPilot joins meetings without permission(9/10)
  • Data used to train AI without explicit consent(8/10)

Sembly AI

No signals

Usability

Otter.ai

  • Transcription accuracy around 85% requires constant editing(8/10)
  • Speaker identification fails - endless 'Speaker 1, Speaker 2'(7/10)
  • Action items and summaries are generic and useless(6/10)
  • Struggles with accents and non-native speakers(6/10)
  • Notes only accessible with Otter account(5/10)

Sembly AI

  • Sembly bot keeps joining meetings I didn't want recorded(5/10)
Pricing

Otter.ai

  • Unauthorized charges and billing nightmares(9/10)
  • Free tier severely limited - 300 minutes, 30-min cap(6/10)
  • 'Shrinkflation' gives fewer minutes for same price(6/10)
  • Confusing cancellation process(7/10)

Sembly AI

  • Sembly AI credits run out and unused credits expire monthly(6/10)
  • Why is Sembly so expensive for teams?(6/10)
  • Sembly refund refused: subscriptions are non-refundable(6/10)
Support

Otter.ai

  • Customer service is non-existent(8/10)

Sembly AI

No signals

Reliability

Otter.ai

  • Fails to capture transcripts reliably(7/10)

Sembly AI

  • Sembly didn't join my meeting (stuck in the lobby or waiting room)(8/10)
  • Sembly recorded but there is no transcript ('meeting audio is too short')(8/10)
  • Sembly stopped recording my recurring meeting(6/10)
Integrations

Otter.ai

No signals

Sembly AI

  • Sembly calendar keeps disconnecting, so meetings are missed(7/10)
  • Sembly integrations are one-way and capped by plan(4/10)
Performance

Otter.ai

No signals

Sembly AI

  • Wrong speaker names and 'Unknown Speaker' in Sembly transcripts(6/10)
  • Is Sembly accurate? Transcripts struggle with fast talk and accents(6/10)
  • Sembly can't record meetings longer than 5 hours(6/10)
Mobile

Otter.ai

No signals

Sembly AI

  • Sembly iPhone app recordings fail to save(7/10)
Customization

Otter.ai

No signals

Sembly AI

  • Sembly changed plans in 2026 and old plans are being retired(4/10)

Pricing Comparison

Otter.ai

Free (Basic)
Free

Users: 1 user (workspace up to 5 members)

Storage: Conversation history limited to the 25 most recent

Limits: 300 min/month, 30-min cap per conversation, 3 lifetime imports, only 25 most recent conversations kept visible, 5 custom vocabulary terms, 20 AI Chat queries/month

File imports are a lifetime cap (3), not monthly; history beyond the 25 most recent conversations is not accessible on Basic; AI Chat capped at 20 queries/month
Pro (Monthly)
$16.99/mo

Users: 1 user

Limits: 1200 minutes/month cap, Single user

Still has minute limits, Higher price vs annual, Minutes don't roll over
Pro (Annual)
Popular
$8.33/yr

Users: 1 user

Limits: 1200 minutes/month, Minutes don't roll over, Locked for year

Large upfront payment, Still has minute limits, Refund difficulties reported
Business (Monthly)
$30.00/mo

Users: Per user

Limits: Per-user pricing; 6,000 import minutes/month cap

Per-user pricing adds up; monthly price is $30 vs $19.99 annual
Business (Annual)
$19.99/yr

Users: Per user

Limits: Annual commitment required; 6,000 import minutes/month cap

Annual commitment; per-user pricing scales with team size
Enterprise
$0.00/mo

Users: Custom

Limits: Requires sales negotiation, Long-term contract

Contracts typically $15,000-$35,000/year, Average around $17,400

Sembly AI

Free
Free

Users: 1 user

Storage: 5 meeting hours; meetings and video kept 1 month

Limits: 5 meeting hours, 1-month history, no integrations, no automations, no MCP, no multi-meeting chat, no custom templates, no analytics

No monthly AI credits after the one-time bonus; meetings are kept only 1 month; the agent still auto-joins meetings while a calendar is connected
Basic
$14.00/mo

Users: 1 user

Storage: Meetings kept 12 months, video 3 months

Limits: Single user only, no multi-meeting chat, no custom templates, no Zapier/MCP

Unused monthly AI credits expire at month end; extra credits cost extra (price shown only at checkout); not refundable
Basic (annual)
$10.00/yr

Users: 1 user

Storage: Meetings kept 12 months, video 3 months

Limits: Single user only

Full year paid upfront and non-refundable
Pro
Popular
$29.00/mo

Users: 1-40 users (per user)

Storage: Meetings kept 24 months, video 6 months

Limits: No HIPAA, SSO, audit log or HD video (MAX only); max 40 users

Per-user pricing; AI credits capped monthly and expire; extra credits sold separately
Pro (annual)
$20.00/yr

Users: 1-40 users (per user)

Storage: Meetings kept 24 months, video 6 months

Limits: Same as Pro

Full year paid upfront and non-refundable
MAX
$39.00/mo

Users: 3-500 users (per user, 3-seat minimum)

Storage: Unlimited meeting history, video 12 months

Limits: Custom contracts, DPAs and a dedicated success manager need Enterprise

3-seat minimum means at least $117/month on monthly billing
MAX (annual)
$30.00/yr

Users: 3-500 users (per user, 3-seat minimum)

Storage: Unlimited meeting history, video 12 months

Limits: Same as MAX

3-seat minimum ($90/month floor), paid a year upfront, non-refundable
Enterprise
Free

Users: 10+ users

Storage: Unlimited or custom retention

Limits: Minimum 10 users

Custom pricing via sales

Feature Comparison

FeatureOtter.aiSembly AI
Core Features
Real-time transcription

~85% accuracy

Meeting bot for Zoom, Google Meet, Teams, Webex

Joins as a guest; waits 10 minutes in a lobby

Meeting recording

Audio and video

Multilingual transcription

40+ languages

AI summaries

Often generic

AI summaries, tasks and risks

Risk/issue tracking on Pro+

Action item detection

Unreliable

Speaker identification

Frequently fails

Custom vocabulary
Meetings longer than 5 hours

Workaround: duplicate the calendar event every 5 hours

AI
Multi-meeting AI chat

Pro and MAX

Studio client documents and slide decks

Uses AI credits

Integrations
Zoom integration

OtterPilot auto-join

Google Meet integration

OtterPilot auto-join

Microsoft Teams integration

OtterPilot auto-join

Mobile app

iOS and Android

Zapier and MCP

Pro and above

Public REST API

Not documented publicly per comparisons

Mobile
In-person audio recording (mobile app)

iOS app; offline recording, upload needs internet

Security
HIPAA and SSO

MAX and Enterprise only

Usability
Collaborative editing

Real-time

Searchable archive

Full transcript search

External sharing

Requires recipient account

Pricing
Free tier

300 min/month, 30-min cap

Student discount

20% off with .edu

Have an app idea? Our small team builds any software: web and mobile apps, games, desktop, AI tools. Price agreed together.

Talk to us
Otter.ai vs Sembly AI 2026 - Problems & Comparison | Try or Bye