GameMaker Problems & Issues

Real user-reported problems, complaints, and limitations for GameMaker. Based on analysis of 12 signals.

Overall score: 66/100

Issues by Category

reliability3 issues

GameMaker YYC compile fails or works in VM but crashes in YYC

Projects that run fine in the VM can fail to compile or crash under YYC. Reported causes include stale caches, outdated Visual Studio components, and code the C++ compiler rejects, such as duplicate script function names.

Frequency: 7%Sentiment: -0.60/1003 sources
Impact
7

GameMaker Android build fails (SDK, NDK, JDK setup)

Android builds depend on matching SDK, NDK and JDK versions and correct paths in Preferences. A newer toolchain than GameMaker expects is a common reason for build failure.

Frequency: 6%Sentiment: -0.60/1003 sources
Impact
7

GameMaker HTML5 export shows a black screen on itch.io

Web exports that work in the IDE can show a blank or stuck page once uploaded. Reported causes include a nested index.html in the zip, the fullscreen embed setting on itch.io, and missing files.

Frequency: 6%Sentiment: -0.50/1003 sources
Impact
6
performance3 issues

GameMaker IDE slow, freezing or project won't open

Users report projects hanging on loading or analyzing, and several large room editor tabs open at once making projects hard to load. Slow compile times are called out as a weak point.

Frequency: 6%Sentiment: -0.60/1003 sources
Impact
7

GameMaker game crashes on startup or randomly closes

Runner crashes show up as fatal errors, white screens or silent exits. Causes range from bad code in the first room to corrupted caches and graphics driver problems.

Frequency: 6%Sentiment: -0.60/1003 sources
Impact
7

Why is my GameMaker game lagging or dropping frames?

Frame drops usually trace to heavy Step events, too many instances, or per-frame draw calls. Debug mode adds its own overhead.

Frequency: 6%Sentiment: -0.40/1002 sources
Impact
6
pricing2 issues

Why do I have to pay to export or sell my GameMaker game?

The free tier is non-commercial only. Making money from a game needs the $99.99 Professional licence, and consoles need an Enterprise subscription. Developers who find out late often cite this as the reason they move to Godot.

Frequency: 7%Sentiment: -0.50/1003 sources
Impact
6

GameMaker subscriptions ended: Creator and Indie not renewing

Old Creator and Indie subscriptions will not renew. Subscribers are pointed to a one-time Professional licence or Enterprise, with discounts based on past payments. Perpetual GMS2 owners get no discount on the new licence.

Frequency: 4%Sentiment: -0.40/1002 sources
Impact
5
support1 issue

GameMaker support is mostly forums and community answers

Most fixes come from the community forum, Reddit and itch.io threads. Official guidance is the manual and the IDE bug reporter (Help > Report A Bug).

Frequency: 5%Sentiment: -0.40/1002 sources
Impact
5
integrations1 issue

GameMaker is 2D only and closed source

GameMaker is built for 2D. It is closed source, which comparison pieces cite against open-source Godot. A new runtime (GMRT) is announced with source access for all tiers.

Frequency: 5%Sentiment: -0.30/1002 sources
Impact
5
mobile1 issue

GameMaker mobile and web export limits

Mobile and web exports need extra platform setup and testing. Console export is Enterprise only and requires approved developer status.

Frequency: 5%Sentiment: -0.40/1002 sources
Impact
6
onboarding1 issue

Is GameMaker good for beginners?

Many users say it gives quick results and is fun for small 2D games, which is why they stay with it. Complexity grows once projects get large.

Frequency: 6%Sentiment: 0.50/1002 sources
Impact
5

Regret Patterns

Common reasons users regret choosing GameMaker.

Finding out about the commercial licence late

Developers build a game on the free tier and then learn they must buy Professional to sell.

Frequency: 7%Before first release

Hitting console limits

Console export needs Enterprise and approved developer status.

Frequency: 5%When planning a console port

Projects outgrowing the IDE

Large projects hang on load or compile slowly.

Frequency: 5%After months of development

Toolchain setup for mobile and YYC

Android and YYC builds need exact SDK, NDK and Visual Studio setups.

Frequency: 6%First mobile or YYC build

Wanting 3D later

A 2D project that wants 3D features pushes developers toward other engines.

Frequency: 4%Mid-project

When GameMaker Breaks Down

Specific scenarios where GameMaker fails or underperforms.

Switching from VM to YYC

Code the VM accepts can fail or crash under YYC.

First Android build

Wrong SDK/NDK/JDK versions or paths stop the build.

Uploading an HTML5 build to itch.io

Nested index.html or embed settings give a blank screen.

Large rooms with many open editor tabs

Opening several full room editors can make loading very slow.

Console release

Requires Enterprise and approved developer status.