Piskel Problems & Issues

Real user-reported problems, complaints, and limitations for Piskel. Based on analysis of 11 signals.

Overall score: 68/100

Issues by Category

reliability3 issues

Piskel lost my sprite or frames did not save

Users report spritesheets saving only the first frame, or saves overwriting the existing image. The official FAQ relies on periodic auto-backups and manual saves, so unsaved work is at risk after a crash.

Frequency: 6%Sentiment: -0.70/1003 sources
Impact
9

Piskel crashes or goes black after pressing Ctrl+Z

Users on GDevelop's forums and the Piskel tracker describe the editor crashing or going black after many undos, losing progress. A related open GitHub report says undo/redo fails in the Librewolf browser.

Frequency: 7%Sentiment: -0.70/1003 sources
Impact
8

Piskel not loading or blank editor

Reports show a black window or missing drawing area, mostly in the Piskel copy bundled in GDevelop, and an open GitHub issue asks whether the browser app broke on a recent Firefox update.

Frequency: 6%Sentiment: -0.60/1003 sources
Impact
8
pricing2 issues

Ads in Piskel and no paid ad-free plan

Piskel shows ads to cover hosting. The FAQ lists Piskel for Kids, an ad blocker or a script as ad-free options and says there is no paid ad-free version yet.

Frequency: 5%Sentiment: -0.30/1001 sources
Impact
3

Is Piskel really free?

Yes, the online editor, offline apps and source code are free and open source, funded by ads. No account is needed for local work.

Frequency: 6%Sentiment: 0.60/1002 sources
Impact
2
integrations2 issues

Piskel does not work from OneDrive or cloud-synced folders (GDevelop)

GDevelop forum replies say Piskel and GDevelop do not support project folders being actively synced by OneDrive or Google Drive, which breaks temp files and saves on Windows.

Frequency: 4%Sentiment: -0.50/1002 sources
Impact
6

Piskel GIF export limits and spritesheet quirks

Changelogs show GIF export previously failed on sprites with more than 100 colors and the no-loop option needed a fix. Spritesheet PNG export has a scale factor from 1 to 32.

Frequency: 4%Sentiment: -0.40/1002 sources
Impact
5
performance1 issue

Piskel crashes or lags on large canvases

Piskel is designed for small sprites. Users report crashes on images larger than roughly 600x600, and the official FAQ itself warns to save often when the performance warning appears.

Frequency: 7%Sentiment: -0.60/1002 sources
Impact
7
support1 issue

Piskel is volunteer-maintained with a growing issue backlog

The GitHub repo shows 71 open issues and 36 open pull requests, and Lospec describes development as stopped. GDevelop staff say the bundled Piskel is a third-party fork that is not really maintained.

Frequency: 6%Sentiment: -0.50/1003 sources
Impact
6
usability1 issue

Piskel has fewer features than Aseprite

Compared with Aseprite, users find Piskel simpler: fewer tools, no indexed color workflow and basic timeline. Lospec calls it a common first editor, not a pro one.

Frequency: 5%Sentiment: -0.30/1002 sources
Impact
5
mobile1 issue

Piskel is weak on phones and tablets

Piskel is built for desktop browsers with mouse and keyboard shortcuts; I found no official mobile app, and touch editing of fine pixels is awkward.

Frequency: 3%Sentiment: -0.30/1001 sources
Impact
4

Regret Patterns

Common reasons users regret choosing Piskel.

Lost work after a crash

A crash or black screen before saving loses the sprite.

Frequency: 7%After a long session

Outgrowing the editor

Projects get larger and the canvas lags or crashes.

Frequency: 6%After the first few projects

Wanting pro tools

Missing indexed color and advanced timeline pushes users to Aseprite.

Frequency: 5%After a few months

Ads annoy

Ad-supported web app distracts from drawing.

Frequency: 4%Early

Stalled development

Open issues pile up with few fixes.

Frequency: 4%Long term

When Piskel Breaks Down

Specific scenarios where Piskel fails or underperforms.

Canvas larger than ~600x600

Lag or crash reported.

Many undo steps then save

Editor goes black.

Project in a OneDrive-synced folder (GDevelop)

Temp-file and save errors.

GIF export of a sprite with many colors

Past releases failed above 100 colors.

Sprite over 1 MB saved to gallery

Gallery rejects; use .piskel file.