Zenefits Problems & Issues
SaasHR, Payroll, and Benefits - All in One Platform
Zenefits offers affordable pricing but is dragged down by severe support deficiencies (25/100), reliability issues including payroll errors and tax filing problems, and limited integrations. The TriNet acquisition has created uncertainty about the platform's future direction. Suitable only for businesses with simple HR needs and tolerance for slow support.
Overview
Zenefits (now TriNet HR Plus) is a cloud-based human resources platform that combines HR management, benefits administration, payroll processing, and compliance tools for small to mid-sized businesses. Founded in 2013, it gained rapid popularity for its all-in-one approach before being acquired by TriNet in 2022.
Signals & Issues
Patterns extracted from real user feedback — not raw reviews.
Users consistently report extremely long wait times when contacting customer support, ranging from 45 minutes to over 3 hours on hold. Some users report waiting nearly 5 months to hear back regarding basic questions and requests. The support team operates primarily through email tickets, making urgent issues difficult to resolve quickly.
Users cannot speak with someone over the phone; everything is done through email by opening cases or tickets. To get a question answered, users must submit to a complex matrix of categories and subjects, and reviewers could rarely find the particular category they needed. Frequent changes in account managers add to the frustration.
When customers cancel, they only get 30 days' access to historical information. After that period, Zenefits charges $500 per year if you want to access your data. This creates significant challenges for data migration and compliance documentation.
Critical payroll failures have been reported where employees didn't receive their pay on time due to bugs in the system. Users report consistent payroll discrepancies between reports and bank transactions occurring almost every pay run. One incident involved the system changing pay frequency from semi-monthly to monthly with a 200% salary error.
Users report frequent payroll tax errors, delayed filings, and poor support for resolving tax-related problems. Some businesses found that Zenefits failed to file annual state tax filings per contracted agreement. When submitting tax-related tickets, it can take weeks to multiple weeks to get a reply, with some users reporting the Tax team reviews tickets within 30-45 business days.
Zenefits experienced a significant glitch during open enrollment that auto-enrolled many employees into wrong benefit plans, including messed-up health, dental, and vision coverage. Even when plans are selected correctly, employees encounter messages like 'no plan available in your state' or 'open enrollment period passed.'
Zenefits completely mishandled employer contributions to employee HSA accounts in the bank they required customers to use. This type of financial mishandling can have serious consequences for both employers and employees relying on these health savings accounts.
After TriNet's acquisition, the company is no longer supporting the standalone HRIS option and will only offer more expensive ASO or PEO plans. Good customer service and pricing transitioned to 'horrible customer service and the push to get everyone on their PEO platform for an insane cost' according to users.
Many core features are sold as add-ons with extra fees including recruiting tools (via JazzHR), HR advisory services, benefits administration through your broker, and payroll processing unless you purchase the highest-tier plan. Implementation fees typically run 5-10% of annual software costs.
Customers report being charged for more employees than they actually have on their team. When requesting Zenefits to update their employee list, they are told they can't make the changes, resulting in significant waste of money each month on phantom employees.
Users describe a significant learning curve with the platform taking forever to get set up. Some customers report spending 40+ hours on initial setup. Navigation is not intuitive and there have been few improvements over 2 years according to reviewers.
Users report having to log in repeatedly even though they've asked their computer and Zenefits to remember the device. This creates daily friction for HR administrators and employees who need frequent access to the platform.
Users explicitly state that claimed integration with QuickBooks Desktop is 'flat out lies.' The platform offers limited integration options with approximately 40 partner applications compared to competitors with 500+ integrations. Poor integrations with current software is a frequently cited complaint.
Most users report recurring bugs, confusing errors, and slow resolution for ongoing technical issues in the platform. The mobile app has been reported as immediately crashing on certain devices like Pixel 4. Reports frequently don't agree with each other, causing confusion for HR administrators.
Some customers found that things Zenefits addressed were done incorrectly and not in compliance with their state's laws. The platform has had bugs when working with state taxes, particularly noted for Washington state, creating potential legal exposure for businesses.
What Users Love
All-in-one platform consolidates HR, payroll, and benefits
Users appreciate having one platform that centralizes HR, payroll, and benefits under one system. This eliminates the need to juggle multiple vendors and provides a unified experience for both administrators and employees.
Affordable per-employee pricing for small businesses
Most reviewers indicate that Zenefits offers good value for money, especially for small to midsized businesses. The flexible pricing model allows companies to pay by headcount and only for the features they use, with pricing 20-40% lower than legacy ERPs.
Automated employee onboarding saves significant time
The automatic onboarding feature is consistently praised, with users noting the time reclaimed from previously spent on HR, onboarding, and payroll processes has more than paid for the service. New hire paperwork and setup can be completed digitally.
Mobile app enables clock-in/out and PTO requests
Users describe the mobile app as a life saver, allowing them to easily clock in and out, track hours, request time off, and see company org charts with coworkers' contact information at their fingertips.
Modern and generally easy-to-navigate interface
Some users praise the modern UI and find it the perfect one-stop-shop for all HR needs with easy navigation. The self-service portal allows employees to manage their own information without constant HR involvement.
Support reps are friendly when you reach them
Customers consistently praise that when they do reach customer service representatives, they are very friendly, knowledgeable, and try to be helpful. Multiple users appreciate dedicated support contacts when assigned.
Pricing Plans
Users: Per employee
Limitations: No performance management, No compensation management, No employee engagement tools
Users: Per employee
Limitations: No performance management, No compensation management, No employee engagement tools
Users: Per employee
Limitations: No employee engagement surveys, No well-being features, No People Hub
Users: Per employee
Limitations: No employee engagement surveys, No well-being features, No People Hub
Users: Per employee
Limitations: Advanced reporting limited, Custom integrations may require additional setup fees
Users: Per employee
Limitations: Advanced reporting limited, Custom integrations may require setup fees
Features
Core HR
- Employee onboarding
Automated workflows
- Employee self-service
Payroll
- Payroll processing
Add-on on lower tiers
- Global payroll
US only
Benefits
- Benefits administration
Broker fees apply
Time Tracking
- Time & attendance
Can be clunky
- PTO management
- Scheduling
Built-in functionality
Talent
- Performance management
Growth plan and above
Usability
- Mobile app
Some device crashes reported
Compliance
- Compliance tools
State-specific issues reported
Support
- Phone support
Email tickets only
Integrations
- QuickBooks Desktop integration
Users report claim is false
- API access
Limited partner integrations
Reporting
- Custom reporting
Limited pre-built reports only
Who Should Use This?
Good Fit
Small businesses (5-50 employees) with basic HR needs
Zenefits provides an affordable all-in-one solution for small businesses that need to centralize HR, payroll, and benefits without enterprise-level complexity. The per-employee pricing makes it cost-effective at this scale.
Neutral
Companies in multiple states with varying compliance
While Zenefits offers compliance tools, users report state-specific issues including incorrect implementations not compliant with state laws and bugs with state taxes (particularly Washington). Verify state-specific compliance before committing.
Finance and accounting teams
The payroll and tax reporting features can save time, but frequent discrepancies between reports and actual bank transactions create reconciliation headaches. Tax filing errors have caused Unemployment Insurance troubles for some businesses.
Startups needing quick, DIY HR setup
While marketed for ease, users report 40+ hour setup times and a significant learning curve. The modern UI is appealing but navigation is not intuitive. If you have dedicated time for onboarding, it can work; if not, expect frustration.
Avoid
Companies requiring responsive customer support
With wait times of 45 minutes to 3+ hours, ticket response times of weeks to months, and no direct phone support, businesses that need quick issue resolution will be severely frustrated. Critical payroll or tax issues can languish unresolved.
Businesses with complex payroll needs
Frequent payroll processing errors, tax filing mistakes, and discrepancies between reports and bank transactions make Zenefits risky for businesses where payroll accuracy is critical. Some users report employees missing paychecks entirely.
HR teams needing extensive integrations
With only ~40 partner integrations compared to competitors offering 500+, and false claims about QuickBooks Desktop integration, businesses relying on specific software ecosystems will find Zenefits limiting. Poor integrations is a top complaint.
Companies considering long-term platform stability
TriNet's acquisition has led to discontinuation of the standalone HRIS option, forcing users to expensive ASO/PEO plans. The company's turbulent history (layoffs, compliance scandals, leadership changes) raises concerns about long-term stability.
Regret Patterns
Common buyer's remorse scenarios reported by users.
Users realize too late that payroll processing has critical bugs. Employees missing paychecks, incorrect tax withholdings, and discrepancies between reports and bank transactions become apparent only after going live with real payroll.
After encountering a serious problem (tax filing error, benefits enrollment issue), users discover that support operates on weeks-to-months timelines. The realization that urgent issues cannot be escalated effectively leads to immediate regret.
Customers who chose Zenefits for affordable standalone HRIS functionality receive notice that this option is being discontinued. The choice becomes either migrate to significantly more expensive ASO/PEO plans or find a new provider entirely.
Despite investing significant time in platform setup, users find the system still isn't fully configured or working as expected. The learning curve is steeper than anticipated, and support cannot expedite the process.
After selecting a base plan, users discover that payroll, benefits administration, recruiting tools, and advisory services are all extra. The actual cost to get full functionality is significantly higher than initial pricing suggested.
Open enrollment period passes with employees auto-enrolled in wrong plans due to system glitches. Correcting coverage takes weeks while employees have incorrect or no coverage, creating legal and morale problems.
After deciding to leave Zenefits, users discover they only have 30 days to export all historical data. Beyond that window, accessing payroll records, tax documents, or employee files costs $500 annually, creating unexpected migration costs.
When It Breaks Down
Scenarios where this product tends to fail users.
When a payroll error causes employees to miss paychecks or receive incorrect amounts, the support system cannot respond quickly enough. Tax-related tickets are reviewed in 30-45 business days, creating untenable situations for time-sensitive payroll corrections.
Businesses using specialized software for accounting (QuickBooks Desktop specifically noted), project management, or industry-specific tools find Zenefits' limited ~40 integrations insufficient. The platform becomes an isolated silo rather than a connected hub.
Companies operating in states with specific HR/payroll requirements discover implementations done incorrectly and not in compliance with state laws. Washington state tax bugs have been specifically noted. Legal exposure increases without reliable compliance.
During the critical annual benefits enrollment window, system glitches auto-enroll employees in wrong plans or show false 'no plan available' errors. The compressed timeline of open enrollment meets slow support response, creating coverage gaps.
Companies that selected Zenefits for affordable standalone HR functionality face forced migration to expensive PEO/ASO plans post-acquisition. The platform that fit their needs no longer exists in the same form.
When employees have urgent questions about benefits, payroll discrepancies, or time-off policies, HR cannot get quick answers from Zenefits support. The email-only, weeks-long response time makes HR look ineffective to employees.
Businesses deciding to leave face a 30-day window to extract all historical data. Complex payroll records, tax documents, and years of employee information must be migrated quickly or access costs $500/year indefinitely.
Alternatives Users Switch To
Gusto
9x mentionedCompanies switch for superior payroll automation and customer support. Gain: AutoPilot for fully automated payroll, better tax handling, unparalleled support levels, simpler setup. Trade-off: Higher base pricing ($39/month + $6/employee), fewer HR features, no built-in scheduling.
Rippling
8x mentionedFounded by Zenefits' former CEO Parker Conrad, businesses switch for expanded functionality. Gain: IT and Finance management beyond HR, 500+ integrations (vs 40), global payroll in 50+ countries, custom reporting. Trade-off: Higher pricing, more complex for simple needs.
BambooHR
7x mentionedMid-sized companies switch for better UX and support. Gain: Simpler/cleaner interface, powerful analytics and reporting, human-centered customer service via phone/email/chat, robust performance management. Trade-off: Higher per-employee cost, payroll is an add-on.
GoCo
5x mentionedSMBs switch for dedicated replacement post-TriNet acquisition. Gain: Purpose-built as Zenefits replacement, retains all-in-one approach, better customer support, no forced PEO migration. Trade-off: Smaller company, fewer advanced enterprise features.
Paychex
4x mentionedCompanies prioritizing payroll reliability switch to this established provider. Gain: Decades of payroll expertise, reliable tax filing, extensive compliance support, dedicated payroll specialists. Trade-off: Less modern UI, can feel enterprise-heavy, higher costs.
Namely
4x mentionedGrowing companies switch for mid-market focus. Gain: Better suited for 50-1000 employee companies, comprehensive talent management, stronger compliance tools. Trade-off: Higher pricing tier, may be overkill for very small businesses.
Frequently Asked Questions
See how Zenefits compares in our Best HR Software rankings, or calculate costs with our Budget Calculator.
Work at Zenefits or spotted something outdated? Suggest a correction — we verify every change against public sources. See our methodology.